Telling the truth is not just a moral responsibility; in legal situations, it is a legal requirement. Whether you are testifying in court or speaking to law enforcement, lying can have serious consequences. Many people wonder: Is it illegal to lie in court or to the police? The answer depends on the circumstances, the type of lie, and the jurisdiction.

This article explains the laws around perjury, false statements, and filing false reports. It also highlights the possible penalties for lying in court or to police officers.

---

Lying in Court: Understanding Perjury

What Is Perjury?

Perjury occurs when a person knowingly makes a false statement under oath during a legal proceeding. This can happen in court, during a deposition, or when signing sworn documents. For it to count as perjury, the lie must involve a material fact—something that could affect the outcome of the case.

Why Is Perjury Serious?

The justice system relies on truthful testimony. When someone commits perjury, it undermines the fairness of the process. Courts treat it as a crime because it can lead to wrongful convictions or acquittals.

Penalties for Perjury

• United States: Up to 5 years in prison under federal law.
• Canada: Up to 14 years in prison, considered an indictable offense.
• United Kingdom: Up to 7 years in prison and/or a fine.

---

Lying to the Police: Is It Always Illegal?

Unlike perjury, lying to the police is not always a crime. The legality depends on what you lie about and when it happens.

Giving False Identification

Providing a fake name or false identification to police during an investigation is usually a crime. For example:

• In California, this is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 6 months in jail.
• In Washington State, it may be treated as a gross misdemeanor, leading to fines and possible jail time.

Filing a False Police Report

Filing a fake report, such as claiming your car was stolen when it was not, is considered illegal in most places.

• In many U.S. states, it is a misdemeanor.
• If the false report leads to wasted resources or endangers lives, it may escalate to a felony.

Lying to Federal Authorities

Even without an oath, lying to federal agencies such as the FBI is illegal under 18 U.S.C. § 1001. This law makes it a felony to knowingly provide false information to federal officers. Convictions can lead to fines and imprisonment.

---

Key Differences Between Perjury and False Statements

Aspect	Perjury	False Statements to Police
Requires an oath?	Yes	No
Applies in court?	Yes	Not necessarily
Is it always a crime?	Yes	Depends on situation
Maximum penalty	5–14 years (jurisdictional)	Varies: fines to federal prison

In 2025, an Australian police officer admitted to lying under oath during a high-profile case involving an NRL player. The officer falsely described attorney-client communications to mislead the court. As a result, he faced perjury charges and sentencing.

This case shows that even law enforcement is not above the law. Courts treat lying seriously regardless of who does it.

Honesty is not just about avoiding punishment. Telling the truth helps preserve fairness, justice, and trust in the legal system. Even if lying seems harmless at the moment, it can lead to long-term legal consequences, criminal charges, and damaged credibility.

---

Conclusion

So, is it illegal to lie in court or to the police?

• In court: Yes, lying under oath is perjury and a serious crime.
• To the police: Sometimes. It depends on whether you lied about your identity, filed a false report, or misled federal agents.

The safest option is always to be truthful—or exercise your legal right to remain silent if answering could incriminate you.